Hard Drive Upgrade

My macbook pro came with a tiny 320 gig hard drive. That simply won’t do. Introduce my brand new out of the bag 750 western digital black hard drive. Why western digital black? They are the fastest baddest drives around, that’s why.

wpid-dsc_6702-2011-02-17-19-071.jpg

I opened the bag and started inspecting it. I noticed something funny on the bottom of the circuit board. Corrosion!

wpid-dsc_6709-2011-02-17-19-071.jpg

Notice the blue tint.

wpid-dsc_6710-2011-02-17-19-071.jpg

This had me worried. Arduino recently had a similar quality control problem. I did not want my brand new super fast drive to have issues.

wpid-dsc_6708-2011-02-17-19-071.jpg

I plugged the 750 into an external enclosure, and tried to copy the data. Thats when the errors really started.

wpid-safari-2011-02-17-19-071.png

My cd rom drive was removed so I could cram in a solid state drive

wpid-dsc_6726-2011-02-17-19-071.jpg

I got a strange error that I have never seen before.

wpid-usernotificationcenter-2011-02-17-19-071.png

I simply formatted the drive, and didn’t worry about it.

I opened my favorite copying software “Carbon Copy Cloner” . Again, I got another error. This isn’t looking good

wpid-carboncopycloner-2011-02-17-19-071.png

By this point I was afraid that the drive might have been bad. I gave it a scan with disk warrior. More errors.

wpid-alsoftdiskwarriorreport-2011-02-17-19-071.png

Another strange error.

wpid-drivegenius3-2011-02-17-19-071.png

Great! I am defiantly thinking this drive is bad. I really don’t want to have to wait for a replacement.

wpid-genericexternalmedia-2011-02-17-19-071.png
I heard about a program called Drive Genius. Their software is fantastic. Unfortunately It wasn’t happy either.

wpid-1____drivegenius3-2011-02-17-19-071.png

Ok time for one last effort. Format it again. What’s this? The drive is now a 2.2 tb drive!!??? Great. I am finally getting past the denial and accepting that this drive could be bad.

wpid-diskutility-2011-02-17-19-071.png

Ok time for one last effort before I send the drive back. I borrow my roomate’s agonizingly slow sata to usb adaptor.

wpid-enclosure-2011-02-17-19-071.jpg

SUCCESS!!!!! It worked without a single issue.
The entire drive copied error free.
        I copied some files back and forth, ran a disk integrity check and made sure that it wasn’t a fluke. The USB to Sata adaptor I was using must have had issues. Strange that I could use any other hard drive without incident. Even stranger was that the errors I was getting were at random times throughout the transfer process.

Here is my theory as to why.

The enclosure that I was using was made before the advanced format drives came out. (if you are unfamiliar with Advanced Format, check out this link here). Basically many new drives are using 4000 byte sectors opposed the the traditional 512 byte sectors we have been using since the floppy era.
My old usb to sata drive appeared to work perfectly for a short while before giving random errors.

The apparent corrosion had nothing to do with the errors I was receiving.

Hopefully this helps someone else running into similar problems.

One last step I did was change my icons to a picture of the actual drives.

wpid-littlesnapper-2011-02-17-19-071.png

Update: My drive has been running great for several months now. I would defiantly recommend this drive to a friend as long as they have a high quality sata to usb adaptor to transfer data.

Advertisements

About spuder
spuder is a "super computer" support engineer by day, and tinkerer / hobbyist by night.

One Response to Hard Drive Upgrade

  1. Pingback: Disable Safe Sleep for Mac « Spencer's Technical Diaries

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: